Controls, Energy + Environment

Thoughts on Bi-Level Switching

Multilevel switching and personal dimming are often lumped together because the goal is the same–providing users a manual choice of light levels. The 2003 Advanced Lighting Guidelines, published by the New Buildings Institute, says they both save about 30% in energy.

multilevel_switching

There is evidence that bi-level switching saves much more energy than personal dimming control, but personal dimming control is more comfortable and satisfying to users.

And when I say bi-level switching, I mean multi-level switching, where the inboard and outboard lamps in 3-lamp fixtures are separately circuited and independently controlled via switches. This allows there light and power levels, not two, specifically 33%, 66% and 100% besides OFF.

In previous research, it demonstrated energy savings of 8-22% (8% classrooms, 16% open offices, 22% private offices, ADM Associates, 2002) and 24% (San Francisco Federal Building project/study).

Personal dimming control has demonstrated energy savings of 6% (National Center for Atmospheric Research or NCAR study) and 11% (National Research Council Canada or NRC study, 2007). The savings are around 10%.

I think people are happier with personal dimming control and tend to stick with light levels they’ve chosen, which are retained in memory. But the energy savings just aren’t as high as when people are forced every time they enter their workspace to make a choice between stark lighting increments that also produce higher savings increments.

  • Milan Javor February 24, 2009, 5:50 PM

    While dimming controls are more comfortable and satisfying to users, we should be careful not to overspecify by calling for dimming where it is not absolutely necessary. We must keep in mind the price we pay for dimming – and I do not mean just the higher capital cost. A dimmable fluorescent ballast is less efficient, requiring more power to produce the same light output. Bi-level switching can also provide a degree of personal control. Dimming may be justified in open offices, where bi-level switching (whether to provide personal control or for daylight harvesting) would be disruptive to (other) occupants, but it is wasteful in spaces such as entry halls, corridors, individual offices and many other applications.

Events

LEDucation 2023
LightFair 2023
IALD Enlighten Europe
Lightovation – Dallas Market Center
2023 IES Annual Conference
Click For More

Careers

Coming Soon - to list your position here, please contact Suelynn at suelynn@lightingsold.com

 

 

 

 

 

Categories

Archives

%d bloggers like this: