Home adoption of smart devices is widespread but shallow, and AI is the lowest priority feature for buyers. A Vivint study finds people want reliability, simplicity, and security more than “intelligence.”
About 85% of U.S. homeowners own at least one smart home device, such as smart TVs, speakers, doorbells, outdoor cameras, or thermostats, but penetration for any single device category remains modest (58% for smart TVs, 38% for smart speakers, 29% for smart thermostats). Despite pervasive AI hype, artificial intelligence ranks dead last among desired smart home features, with only 12% of homeowners naming it a priority. Instead, people care most about practical benefits: 54% prioritize ease of use, 38% real-time alerts and notifications, 36% battery backup for power outages, 33% remote access and convenience, 33% voice or app control, and 29% of millennials (only) emphasize security.
The data undercuts common smart home marketing, which often leads with “smartness” and AI-driven features. The study suggests homeowners value reliability, interoperability, and concrete problem-solving—security, power continuity, energy savings—far more than abstract intelligence or novelty. AI is not yet a compelling selling point on its own; it must be packaged as a means to simpler, more dependable experiences, not as a headline feature.
Complexity continues to drag down adoption and satisfaction. Twenty percent of homeowners say “too many apps” is a barrier, and 18% cite incompatibility with existing devices. The article notes that the replacement cycle for home appliances is much longer than for phones or laptops, so constant platform shifts, app changes, or discontinued support hit harder. An example is Google cutting support and remote control for older but still-functioning Nest thermostats, which erodes trust in smart ecosystems that depend on cloud services and apps. This fragility contrasts with expectations that home infrastructure should last many years without breaking due to software decisions.
There is a “quietly radical” 15% of households that remain without any smart devices. These people avoid app setups, late-night alerts, Bluetooth glitches, subscriptions, and abrupt support changes. For them, simplicity is not Luddism but a functional choice aligned with cost, privacy, and reliability concerns, rather than merely older or technophobic. They are unconvinced that today’s smart home proposition offsets the friction, risks, and ongoing maintenance of connected devices.
At the same time, smart home tech is indispensable for a minority: 20% of respondents say they cannot imagine life without their devices. Adoption strongly skews younger, with 96% of Gen Z and 93% of millennials owning at least one smart device. Yet more than half of consumers are “show me” buyers who wait for proven track records before embracing new products, signaling that future growth depends on demonstrated reliability and value, not buzz.
The path forward for smart home providers is to build integrated systems that deliver genuine personalization, convenience, and accessibility, simplifying daily life rather than adding clutter and cognitive load. The report indicates that success will come from reducing friction, ensuring long-term support, and making devices work together seamlessly, with AI in a supporting role rather than as the star attraction.
More information is available here.
Image above: Pixabay.com
You must be logged in to post a comment.